He and his colleagues recently analyzed news reports from 2000

Why Are So Many Women Getting Canada Goose Jackets Double Mastectomies They Might Not Need

cheap Canada Goose Last December Kathy Bressler got the news so many of us fear: A biopsy revealed that a suspicious mass in her right breast was in fact cancer. Her surgeon told her she was a good candidate for lumpectomy because the tumor was smaller than cheap canada goose uk 2 centimeters they could remove it and preserve both her breasts. But Bressler’s mother and grandmother had died of breast cancer, so instead she told her surgeon she wanted a double mastectomy. cheap Canada Goose

canada goose black friday sale “My mom had a single mastectomy the first time she was diagnosed, in her 30s then a second mastectomy canada goose black friday sale when they found cancer in her other breast 20 years later. And in between she had umpteen mammograms and constant worry,” says Bressler, a 56 year old hospital administrator in Tacoma, Wash. “I didn’t want to go through that. I wanted to take them both off and be done with it.” canada goose black friday sale

Canada Goose Parka Even a decade ago, treating cancer in one breast by removing both known as Canada Goose Outlet a contralateral prophylactic mastectomy (“contralateral” meaning opposite side, and “prophylactic” meaning preventive) would have sounded like a radical choice. But these days, CPM is becoming increasingly common a trend that worries some doctors because, in most cases, there’s no compelling medical reason to get rid of the healthy breast. “More newly diagnosed women are coming to the clinic, canada goose store and instead of asking, ‘What are my treatment options?, they’re saying, ‘I want both breasts removed,'” says Michael Sabel, MD, chief of surgical oncology at the University of Michigan. “That’s not necessarily the wrong choice, but we canada goose clearance want to make sure patients are doing it for the right reasons and know what they’re getting into.” Canada Goose Parka

What driving the surge

The numbers are eye opening: In a study published earlier this year, researchers at Brigham and Women’s Hospital found that the proportion of women diagnosed with stage 1 to stage 3 cancer in one breast who decided to have CPM more than tripled between 2002 and 2012, from Canada Goose Jackets Outlet less than 4 percent to nearly 13 percent. “Double mastectomy isn’t without risks, especially when you have reconstruction, too which the majority of women choose to do. And it doesn’t increase your chance of surviving the cancer, because breast cancer is unlikely to spread to the other breast.” In other words, if your goal is to beat the cancer you have, removing a healthy Canada Goose Online breast will most likely give you little, if any, survival advantage. So why are so many women doing it?

Worry tops the list. When Christine Hunt, 48, of Brooklyn, Conn., was diagnosed with stage 1, chemo resistant breast cancer in 2014, the same year her mom was diagnosed for a second time, she knew she wanted a double mastectomy. Like Kathy Bressler’s mother, Hunt’s mom had gotten a single mastectomy and then developed cancer in her other breast decades later. “I didn’t want to have to constantly worry when or if the other shoe was going to drop,” says Hunt.

buy canada goose jacket cheap It’s natural for women who are diagnosed with breast cancer to feel anxious about cancerous cells cropping up in their other breast and it can happen, says Todd Tuttle, MD, chief of Canada Goose Coats On Sale surgical oncology at the University of Minnesota Medical School. “But fear can cause you to grossly overestimate the risk,” he says. In a survey Dr. Tuttle and his colleagues conducted several years ago, they found that women who had cancer in one breast thought their odds of developing a potentially deadly tumor in the other were over 30 percent “far higher than the actual risk of 4 to 5 percent,” he says. buy canada goose jacket cheap

Canada Goose online RELATED: A Complete Guide to Breast Cancer Screening Canada Goose online

Doctors may be inadvertently fueling women’s anxiety by ordering more MRIs of both breasts for those who are canada goose clearance sale newly diagnosed, adds Dr. Sabel. Because MRIs provide more sensitive images of the breast tissue than mammograms, they’re more likely to find suspicious looking but ultimately canada goose factory sale harmless abnormalities in the cancer free breast. “That may scare some women into thinking that they should have the healthy breast removed just in case,” says Dr. Sabel.

canada goose coats But even if you understand the low likelihood of developing cancer canada goose uk black friday in the other breast, it can still be difficult to quell your fear fear that spikes every time you have a mammogram or feel something unusual in your breast, notes Shoshana Rosenberg, ScD, an epidemiologist at the Dana Farber Cancer Institute in Boston. Over the course of a decade, Nicole Witt, 47, of Brandon, Fla., endured seven biopsies for suspicious mammography findings before finally having a double mastectomy in 2013. “My sister was diagnosed with breast cancer in her 30s, so canada goose I started getting mammograms really early,” she says. “I had so many biopsies, I canadagooseoutletjackets felt like I was having a mastectomy piece by piece. It was incredibly stressful. When my last biopsy canada goose uk outlet revealed cells that weren’t cancerous but weren’t 100 percent normal, either, my doctor and I agreed I should have a double mastectomy. It’s been such a relief to put that issue behind me.” canada goose coats

canada goose clearance sale The younger you are, the more time you have to potentially develop a second cancer and that can make anxiety a potent consideration for women in their 20s and 30s, says Rosenberg. “You can tell a young woman that the risk of contralateral breast cancer is low, but her risk of getting cancer in the first place was low so reassurances only go so far. And if women have young children, often the first thing they think of is wanting to be around to watch their kids grow up,” she says. “If you don’t think you can bear the stress and worry of having mammograms every six months, a prophylactic mastectomy might be the right choice. That said, surgery probably isn’t the best remedy for anxiety.”Yet it’s not just anxiety driving the trend; there’s also been a subtle attitudinal shift in favor of double mastectomy that may be encouraging more women these days to go for the more extreme treatment. “As medical historians have pointed out, 50 years ago doctors were more inclined to recommend that women have radical mastectomies, so women felt that taking charge of their health meant saving their breasts by having a lumpectomy with radiation,” says Karen Hurley, PhD, a clinical psychologist in New York City who specializes in hereditary cancer risk. Today, in part because of news coverage of genetic mutations, women tend to see double mastectomy as the empowered choice, says Hurley: “There’s not a lot of talk about the bravery of women who choose to keep their breasts and maintain their screening regimens.” canada goose clearance sale

canada goose store That change in attitude stems partly from the media’s coverage of celebrities with breast cancer, says Dr. Sabel. He and his colleagues recently analyzed news reports from 2000 to 2012 years when the rate of CPM climbed ever higher and found that, when a star had a bilateral (double) mastectomy, her treatment was the focus of the story, the coverage tended to be positive, and the risks and benefits of the choice weren’t clarified. “In articles Canada Goose sale about celebrities who had unilateral mastectomies or lumpectomies, their treatment often wasn’t even mentioned,” says Dr. Sabel. “Celebrities can impact trends, even when it comes to major health decisions.” canada goose store

canada goose But one important fact often isn’t clear in media coverage: Some celebrities who have had a double mastectomy actually carry a genetic mutation that puts them at extraordinarily high risk of breast cancer. with a mutation in their BRCA1 or BRCA2 gene including Angelina Jolie, who grabbed headlines canada goose

Canada Goose Jackets in 2013 when she had a prophylactic double mastectomy the surgery can reduce their odds of developing the disease by more than 90 percent. The National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN), the organization that creates evidence based clinical practice guidelines, has deemed prophylactic double mastectomy a viable option for women with genetic mutations. Canada Goose Jackets

canada goose deals RELATED: 5 Simple Things That Could Cut Your Breast uk canada goose Cancer Risk canada goose deals

buy canada goose jacket However, the NCCN recommends against CPM for women who are diagnosed with breast cancer in one breast and don’t carry a high risk mutation. Most breast surgeons agree with that advice. A recent survey of 601 breast surgeons revealed that, while 95 percent were comfortable performing canadian goose jacket CPM on women with BRCA mutations, just 34 percent were comfortable doing the surgery on women of average risk. In July, the American Society of Breast Surgeons issued a statement that CPM should be discouraged for average risk women with cancer in one breast. buy canada goose jacket

canadian goose jacket “I always mention contralateral mastectomy as an option but if the patient isn’t likely to benefit, I explain why I wouldn’t advocate for that approach,” says Dr. Sabel. “But most patients who opt for it have already decided that’s the route they want to take before they talk to a surgeon, even though the majority of them don’t have any known mutations that put them at increased risk of breast cancer.” canadian goose jacket

Two other factors probably play a role in women’s decisions to have CPM: First, the surgery is covered by insurance. “I believe it should be covered, but women would undoubtedly feel different about it if it weren’t,” says Shelley Hwang, MD, chief of breast surgery at Duke University. Second, mastectomy and reconstruction techniques have improved and it’s easier to create symmetrical breasts if you do both sides at the same time, says Deanna Attai, MD, a breast surgeon and assistant clinical professor of surgery at the David Geffen School of Medicine at the University of California, Los Angeles. “Many women are interested in a more natural breast appearance, minimal scarring and symmetry,” says Dr. Attai. “My husband and I were going to start trying to have children, and I really wanted to breast feed,” she says. canada goose uk shop But when her doctor told her that the type of tumor she had invasive lobular carcinoma slightly increased her risk of developing cancer in the unaffected breast, she decided to have a double mastectomy and sacrifice her ability to breast feed.

canada goose coats on sale “I don’t have any known genetic mutation, but I’ve watched two aunts get diagnosed with the disease and one die in her 30s. I didn’t want to live in fear uk canada goose outlet for the rest of my life,” she says. “Still, when I was pregnant with my son a few years later, I really canada goose coats mourned the loss of my breasts, and there have been consequences I didn’t expect, like the fact that I have no sensation in my breasts” a common side effect of mastectomy and reconstruction. canada goose coats on sale

Most women who get CPM don’t regret their decision, but studies show that many wish they had known more about the trade offs before embarking on the procedure, says Dr. Hwang. It’s important to understand, for instance, that women who undergo CPM don’t have a higher quality of life, on canada goose coats on sale average, than those who choose less invasive treatment options and they may even have lower levels of physical well being, according to a study by Dr. Hwang, because the surgery itself has side effects that can cause long lasting problems. For instance, up to one third of women have chronic pain after mastectomy with reconstruction, says Dr. Hwang. “You can get infections, too, and nonhealing wounds,” she adds. “Those factors might not change your mind, but you should be aware of them before you commit to the surgery.”

Canada Goose Outlet Having a Canada Goose Parka clear grasp of the risks and benefits is especially critical for BRCA negative women diagnosed with ductal carcinoma in situ (also known as stage 0 cancer), precancerous abnormal cells in the milk ducts 31 percent of whom are choosing CPM, per a recent study, even though low risk DCIS can often be safely treated by doing nothing but getting regular mammograms to make sure the condition hasn’t progressed, says Dr. Hwang. “Mastectomy is a big price cheap Canada Goose to pay for a disease that’s unlikely to kill you,” she notes. Canada Goose Outlet

canada goose clearance Kathy Bressler says the fact that a double mastectomy was far more invasive than a lumpectomy didn’t worry her beforehand, but it ended up being a bigger surgery than she had anticipated. Immediately afterward, the skin on one of her breasts started dying; to save it, she had to lie for hours in a hyperbaric chamber filled with 100 percent oxygen every day for five weeks. “Because the surgeon cuts your muscles to make room for the tissue expanders, which they put in prior to implants as part of the reconstruction, you have T. rex arms at first,” she adds, “and my pain was extreme Canada Goose online for the first two weeks.” Mastectomy with reconstruction can require multiple, hours long surgeries (each with weeks of recovery) spanning many months. canada goose clearance

Canada Goose sale In contrast, lumpectomy is a comparatively simple operation. “We make a small incision, it carries low risk, and most women have an excellent cosmetic result,” says Dr. Sabel. (However, most patients still require radiation.) Canada Goose sale

But Bressler has buy canada goose jacket cheap no regrets. Her postsurgical pathology report revealed three more tumors in her right breast. Her cancer also turned out to be triple negative, a particularly aggressive subtype. “My mammogram had been clean, and an ultrasound showed only the first tumor,” she says. “So I don’t look at lumpectomy buy canada goose jacket wishfully. I think the fear of another bout would have always been there and now I just don’t have that.”.